Jojoba Eye Pencil Smudging? Fix It with These Tips

Quick answer

If your jojoba eye pencil smudges, the most likely culprit is excess oil on your eyelids or a too-creamy formula. Start by prepping your lids with a matte eyeshadow or translucent powder before lining, and always set the pencil with a matching powder shadow. If smudging persists, switch to a waterproof formula like a waterproof mascara for the lash line instead.

Why your jojoba eye pencil might be smudging

The jojoba eye pencil from Ereperez is deliberately creamy and blendable, thanks to its jojoba seed oil base. That makes it gentle for sensitive eyes and perfect for a smoky look, but the same oils that help it glide on can also break down faster on oily eyelids. If you have naturally oily lids or you’ve applied a rich eye cream, the pencil may not stay put as long as you’d like.

Another factor is application technique. If you line your waterline heavily or don’t let the pencil set for a few seconds before blinking, the creamy formula can transfer. And if you’re using the pencil alone without any setting product, the natural oils in the formula remain active, increasing the chance of smudging throughout the day.

Simple fixes for long-lasting eye makeup

Start with a clean, dry eyelid. Skip heavy eye creams before applying the pencil, or wait until the cream is fully absorbed. Dust a thin layer of translucent powder or a matte eyeshadow over your entire lid and under the lower lash line. This absorbs excess oil and gives the pencil a drier surface to grip.

Apply the jojoba eye pencil in short, light strokes rather than one long line. Let it sit for 10–15 seconds before opening your eyes fully. Then, take a small angled brush and gently pat a matching powder eyeshadow over the liner. This locks the creamy pigment in place without dulling its color. For extra insurance, finish with a light spritz of setting spray.

When to consider a different product

If you’ve tried powder and setting spray but still see smudging by midday, your eye area may be too oily for a creamy pencil. In that case, consider using the jojoba eye pencil only for tightlining or the upper lash line, and switch to a waterproof option for the lower waterline. The avocado waterproof mascara from Ereperez is designed to be smudge-proof, tear-proof, and waterproof, making it a reliable alternative for the lower lashes. It also contains nourishing oils to support lash health.

Diagnosis: Why your jojoba eye pencil smudges

• Symptom: The pencil transfers onto the lower eyelid or fades unevenly within a few hours of application. Check for visible smudging after 2–3 hours.
• Likely cause: Excess oil on the eyelids (natural or from skincare) interacting with the creamy jojoba oil base of the pencil. Try a dry lid prep before your next application.
• Corrective action: Set the pencil with a matching powder eyeshadow or translucent powder. Use a setting spray for extra hold. If smudging stops, this method works for you.
• If it still smudges: Your eye area may be too oily for a creamy pencil. Use the jojoba eye pencil only on the upper lash line and switch to a waterproof mascara for the lower lashes. The avocado waterproof mascara is a reliable alternative.

Products mentioned in this guide

• jojoba eye pencil: A creamy, blendable natural eyeliner formulated with jojoba seed oil, gentle enough for sensitive eyes and the delicate waterline. One plastic-free pencil lines, shades and smudges, so definition never comes at the cost of comfort or the planet. The jojoba oil makes it ideal for a soft, smoky look, but it also means the pencil stays creamy and may need extra setting on oily lids.
• avocado waterproof mascara: A world-first vegan waterproof mascara since 2005. A makeup bag must-have for smudge-proof, tear-proof and waterproof lashes. Contains nourishing avocado and mamey oils to help regenerate and stimulate lash growth. If the pencil still smudges, using this waterproof mascara on the lower lashes gives you a long-lasting, smudge-free alternative without sacrificing nourishment.